Science, Objectivity and Political Responsibility in the Litigation of Two Oil Spills

Free Public Lecture

Science, Objectivity and Political Responsibility in the Litigation of Two Oil Spills

Room 155 Theatre D
Old Arts

Map

More information

T: 0432239183

ghumkhor@unimelb.edu.au

This presentation examines the role of scientific experts and expertise in legal proceedings. It compares the decisions made by two scientists contributing to litigation concerning the Exxon Valdez oil spill in Alaska in 1989 and petroleum contamination in the Ecuadorian Amazon by ChevronTexaco from the mid-1960s through to the early 1990s.

In the first example, a prominent environmental sociologist was asked to conduct research intended to reduce the punitive damages award against the oil company. In the second case, a geochemist with expertise on groundwater pollution was implicated in federal racketeering and corruption charges filed against the lawyer representing the plaintiffs in the case.

The presentation draws on court transcripts and ‘life writing’ associated with the two contrasting examples to ask questions about science, objectivity and political responsibility.

Presenter

  • Professor Stuart  Kirsch
    Professor Stuart Kirsch, Professor of Anthropology